1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Paying for chores

Should You Pay Kids for Chores? The Case For, Against and a Middle Way

Chore Chart Maker team7 min read

There is no single right answer, and experts don't all agree. Paying for chores teaches that money comes from work; not paying teaches that everyone helps because they live there. Many families settle on a hybrid: everyday family jobs are unpaid, a separate allowance teaches money skills, and extra jobs can earn extra money.

Below are the honest arguments on both sides, what pediatric and money-education organizations actually say, how to set up the hybrid, and how the answer changes as kids grow.

The case for paying kids for chores

  • It mirrors real life. Adults get paid for work. A child who earns $3 for washing the car feels the link between effort and money in a way a free allowance can't show.
  • It can motivate. Some kids, especially goal-driven 8- to 12-year-olds saving for something specific, will do jobs for money that they'd drag their feet on otherwise.
  • It gives money meaning. HealthyChildren.org, the American Academy of Pediatrics' family site, notes that chores can be one way to earn an allowance, and that assigning chores gives a sense of accomplishment and meaning to the money earned.
  • It teaches pricing and negotiation. Older kids learn that a bigger job is worth more, and that agreeing on terms first prevents arguments later.
  • It's an option the AAP lists. Its age-appropriate chores page mentions tangible rewards, like allowances and stickers tied to completed chores, as something you may want to consider.

The case against paying for chores

  • Kids can opt out. The University of Nevada, Reno Extension warns that when chores and allowance are tied together, a child who no longer needs the money may refuse the chores. "I don't want the dollar" is a hard argument to beat.
  • It turns help into a transaction. If every job has a price, kids start asking "what do I get?" for carrying in a grocery bag. Utah State University Extension notes that some parents prefer chores to be tied to being a member of the family.
  • Rewards can crowd out the habit. A University of Arizona family-resources article cautions that relying too much on rewards can lead children to do chores only for payment, or to stop when the reward is gone.
  • It mixes two lessons. If money is both a wage and the tool for learning to budget, a child who has a bad chore week also loses the chance to practice saving and spending.
  • It gets expensive and fiddly. Paying per task means tracking every task. Many parents give up by week three.

What money educators recommend

Read a handful of extension and pediatric sources and a pattern appears. Most separate family work from extra work:

  • University of Nevada, Reno Extension: keep chores and allowance separate; chores are unpaid family responsibilities, and extra work can earn money if you agree on the pay before the work begins.
  • Utah State University Extension: "think twice" before tying allowance to chores; pay for extra-large jobs like washing windows or raking leaves, or reward with non-money treats.
  • Financial Security for All (Cooperative Extension): expect children to take part in routine family chores without pay, and create "special" chores that let them earn money.
  • University of Arizona Life & Work Connections: recommends keeping chores and allowance separate, while saying it's fine to pay for extra chores when a child is saving for something special.
  • HealthyChildren.org (AAP): takes no hard line. It says each family needs to decide what works, and lists allowances tied to chores as one possible reward.

So the mainstream advice is not "never pay" or "always pay". It's "don't pay for the basics".

The hybrid: three kinds of jobs

Here is a setup that borrows the best of both sides and is simple enough to keep running.

TypeExamplesPaid?
Self-careBrush teeth, get dressed, pack school bag, screens off on timeNever. These are just growing up.
Family jobsMake the bed, clear your plate, tidy your room, feed the pet, empty the dishwasherNo. Everyone who lives here helps.
Extra jobsWash the car, rake the whole yard, clean out the garage shelf, wash windowsYes, at a price agreed before starting

Alongside this, a small regular allowance (if you give one) is paid no matter what, because its job is to teach saving and spending. See how much allowance by age for amounts.

Make a price list for extra jobs

Post a short "job board" on the fridge with jobs and prices. Agree on what "done" means for each one, so nobody argues about a half-washed car. A sample for a 10-year-old:

Extra jobSample price
Wash the family car (with a parent nearby)$3–$5
Rake the front yard$3–$5
Pull weeds from one garden bed$1–$3
Clean out the fridge with a parent$2–$4
Clean windows and mirrors on one floor$2–$4

Prices are examples; set yours to fit your budget. The Nevada extension guide suggests paying roughly what the work would be worth to outside help, and warns that overpaying teaches the wrong lesson about earning.

What happens when family jobs are skipped?

Because family jobs aren't paid, you can't "fine" a child for skipping them. Use ordinary, related consequences instead: toys left out go on a shelf until tomorrow, laundry not in the hamper doesn't get washed, the extra-job board is closed until family jobs are done. That last one is the hybrid's quiet strength: earning is available only once the basics are covered.

Utah State's guide also advises against docking allowance often for misbehavior, and the Nevada guide says not to use allowance as a reward or punishment at all. Keep money out of discipline, and keep it attached to work and budgeting.

Paying for chores by age

Ages 2 to 5: stars, not money

Preschoolers love helping and don't need to be paid for it. They also can't connect a coin today with a toy in three weeks. Use stars or stickers and praise. A reward chart with a small prize at the end works better than cash. If you want to start money lessons, let them hand coins to a cashier or drop a few into a clear jar.

Ages 6 to 9: start the hybrid

This is a good time to introduce a small allowance and one or two simple extra jobs, like matching all the socks in the laundry basket or raking leaves into a pile. Keep prices in coins and pay the same day. Kids this age are often eager to earn toward something specific, so a picture of the goal next to the chart helps.

Ages 10 to 12: a real job board

Preteens can handle a menu of extra jobs with prices, deciding for themselves whether a $4 car wash is worth their Saturday morning. Talk about what they're saving for and how many jobs it will take. Keep family jobs firm and unpaid; at this age they include bigger tasks like taking out the trash or loading the dishwasher.

Teens: bigger jobs, outside work

Teens can take on paid jobs with real value: mowing the lawn (the AAP says children should be at least 12 to use a walk-behind power mower), deep-cleaning the car, babysitting younger siblings for an evening. Many also start earning outside the home. That's a good time to shift from per-job pay at home to a monthly budget they manage, with family jobs still expected. Our chores for teens page has ideas.

Things to avoid whichever way you choose

  • Paying for grades. Utah State's guide advises against it, and Financial Security for All recommends not using money to reward or punish grades or behavior.
  • Changing the deal mid-week. Agree on jobs and prices up front, then stick to them until the next family meeting.
  • Paying for unfinished work. Agree on what done looks like. "Car washed" means outside rinsed and dried, not one wet door.
  • Making siblings' deals identical. Fair means fitted to age and ability, not the same list for a 6-year-old and a 12-year-old.
  • Bargaining every job. If a child starts negotiating the price of clearing their plate, that's the signal to move it back into unpaid family jobs.

How to start this week

  1. Sit down for ten minutes as a family and sort your jobs into self-care, family jobs and extra jobs.
  2. Decide whether you'll give a separate allowance, and if so, how much and on what day.
  3. Write a short extra-job board with prices and what "done" means.
  4. Make a chart so everyone can see their family jobs. The family chore chart maker fills in age-appropriate jobs for each child, and you can switch the reward to stars, points or pocket money.
  5. Review it in a month. Adjust prices, swap jobs, and add one new responsibility for anyone who's ready.

Whichever path you pick, consistency matters more than the model. A simple system you keep for a year beats a perfect one you drop in February.

Frequently asked

Is it good to pay kids for chores?

It can be, for the right jobs. Paying for extra jobs teaches that money comes from work. Paying for everyday family jobs, like clearing your own plate, risks teaching that helping at home is optional if you don't need money. Many families pay only for jobs beyond the basics.

How much should I pay my child per chore?

Agree on the price before the job starts and keep it modest: small jobs might earn a quarter to a dollar for younger kids, and bigger extra jobs, like washing the car, a few dollars for older kids. One extension guide suggests paying roughly what the job would be worth to outside help, and not overpaying.

What chores should not be paid?

Most money educators suggest not paying for routine family jobs and personal care: making your bed, clearing your plate, picking up your own things, brushing teeth. These are part of being a member of the household. Save money for bigger or optional extra jobs.

What if my child says they don't want the money and won't do the chore?

That is the main risk of paying for everyday chores. The fix is to separate the two: family jobs are expected and unpaid, with ordinary consequences if skipped, and only extra jobs are paid. Then turning down money only means turning down extra work.

Should I pay my child for good grades?

Extension money guides generally advise against paying for grades or using money to reward or punish behavior. Grades and behavior work better with praise, attention and privileges, while money lessons stay tied to work and budgeting.